Cakes

Order Cakes Online!

Baking Amazing Cakes Since 1984

World Famous Cakes

Taste the Penn Street Bakery Difference

Often imitated, never duplicated! Our baker selects from only the finest ingredients: sweet butter, sour cream, sun-ripened fruits and premium nuts, to create a uniquely rich & scrumptious cakes.

Each Penn Street Cake is a generous 3 pounds. You can dress it up with a garnish of fresh fruits, sauces or whipped cream. A cake serves 24 people. Ounce per ounce, it’s among the best values in catalog sales!

The Finest Ingredients

Our gourmet baked goods contain only the finest ingredients: real butter, wholesome oats, plump raisins, brown sugar. 

Hand Made Cakes

All cake inclusions are prepared in-house by hand, including; chopping pecans, walnuts and macadamia nuts, zesting fresh lemons and peeling/chopping fruits such as fresh Georgia Peaches and Granny Smith Apples. A skilled Baker adds the distinctive flavor swirl found in most of our cake flavors by hand.

Our Gourment

Carrot Cake

People LOVE this cake!
Click here

Our World Famous

Bundt Cakes

Gourmet!
Click here

Purchase Cakes Online

Our famous bundt cakes look and taste different from other cakes. They are uniquely moist, like a “marriage of cheesecake and pound cake”. Our gourmet bundt cakes are imitated time and time again – but pound for pound our cake reigns king.

Shop All Cakes

Cake Flavors

Apple Maple Walnut

Moist and satisfying, our Apple Maple Cake is just right for the fun times of autumn; from tailgating to color-touring, serve it often! Available mid September through December.

Blueberry

Blueberry lovers will rave about this cake from morning 'til night. It's loaded with blueberries and swirled with blueberry filling.

Cherry Almond

Sliced almonds adorn the top of the cake, and what a surprise... you'll love the Michigan dried cherries and a swirl of tart cherry filling inside the almond flavored cake.

Cinnamon Pecan

Blueberry lovers will rave about this cake from morning 'til night. It's loaded with blueberries and swirled with blueberry filling.

Double Chocolate Raspberry

This is how it all started. Perhaps that's why cinnamon pecan is our most popular seller. The cake is rich and buttery, and the cinnamon, brown sugar, and pecan swirl and a subtle crunch. This cake is at-home in the kitchen or the boardroom. Great any time of day, from breakfast to a midnight snack, you'll love it!

Georgia Peach

Pieces of fresh peach and sour cream, mmm, it's "Peaches & Cream" in a cake! Each delicious bite is sweet and fruity, it's the perfect dessert for a lazy summers's evening. Available only while the Georgia Peach crop peaks (approximately mid-July through Labor Day).

Hawaiian Macadamia Nut

Subtle, yet rich, the flavor can only be that of the Macadamia nut. Ground nut meats flavor the batter and Macadamia nut chunks are swirled through the center of the cake. A wonderful cake for high-tea, an evening indulgence, or a fire-side picnic.

Honey Orange Poppy

Experience the "Sunshine and Sweetness" of our delicious Honey Orange cake. Each slice bursts with fresh zest of orange, pure honey, and a sprinkle of poppy seeds. It is a delightful treat for breakfast or brunch.

White Chocolate Raspberry

We like the elegant eye-appeal of this cake. Sumptuous White Chocolate throughout the cake, rippled with a Red Raspberry swirl, this cake is alive with rich rum flavor and Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla. Fancy as a dessert, comfortable for a brunch.

Zesty Lemon

Lemon Lovers will savor the bright zing of this wonderful cake. It contains a generous amount of freshly grated lemon zest. Appealing at all times of the day, and especially delicious with a flavored tea.